Is ESN Wrong for Criticizing Worldwide Church of God
 and its Authoritarian Offshoots?

 

Automatically discounting information that appears to be "lies," without examining the evidence, is a way to keep truthful--and very painful--information at bay.  To investigate further into the charges would "change our life" and most of us frankly like things the way they are no matter how wrong it might be. We don't like the idea of losing our friends, our beliefs, and our purpose in life, especially if we sacrificed time, money, or a lifetime to it. To think that we went hungry, lost a job, or let a loved one die for the "wrong cause" would leave us filled with anguish and not knowing what to do and where to go. We also like to think that we are far too intelligent to have been deceived by "a religious cult"1 or a con-artist. To admit that we were programmed by leaders who only wanted to control us and exploit us emotionally and financially is to experience deep feelings of betrayal and loss, along with questioning our own judgment for letting it happen. [Read letter to ESN: One of the Hardest Things is to Admit You Have Been Wrong] We don't like to live with these thoughts, so it is much easier to dismiss them.

Before you write our site off as filled with lies, gossip, and bitterness, do you have the courage to ask yourself and your minister the following questions?
  1. Who was Herbert W. Armstrong?  (The WCG ministers were carefully
    instructed to answer, "He was the founder of the WCG."  (The Philadelphia Church of God will say he was the "end-time Elijah." Other high demand splinter groups such as Living Church of God, Restored Church of God, etc. will say similar things to show they believe HWA was "used of God," "restored the true gospel," was "God's end time man," etc.) Ask them if HWA was ever called "God's end-time Apostle." If you were in the WCG before 1985, this term was commonplace.
    (Read the exact quotes from chapter 6 of  Mystery of the Ages, pp. 267, 269.) Ask them why Herbert Armstrong was downgraded from "God's only true end-time Apostle" to a mere "founder"? (The PCG will answer along the lines of, "The WCG has turned Laodocian.")
  2. Did Herbert Armstrong ever make claims or prophecies that didn't come true?  If they didn't come true, then doesn't that qualify him as a "false prophet" by Biblical definition? (See: Deut. 18:20-22. Also read our article, Did Herbert W. Armstrong Set Dates? to see some of his prophecies.) If your minister says his prophecies have "not yet come to pass," read this Q&A on that subject, which will also shows how people in O.T. times knew whether someone qualified as a true prophet of God. Can a false prophet be a founder of a "true church"? 
  3. Did Herbert Armstrong commit incest with his younger daughter Dorothy at the time he was founding the "one true church"? Weren't others aware of this? (Listen and see if they justify his actions with words similar to: "David committed adultery and he was a man after God's own heart" or "we all sin.")  Read: "None of God's Servants Were Perfect" (for those who like to use this reasoning). Ask them if HWA ever asked Dorothy to "forgive him"? (Don't you ever wonder why none of his children are in the WCG?)
  4. When you entered the WCG was there any type of pamphlet that informed you of all the beliefs of the group, and all that would be expected of you, or was important information hidden from you under the pretense of "babes can't digest meat, so we only give them the milk"?  If such a pamphlet existed, it would have to contain the following information:
This Body of Jesus Christ believes that it is THE ONLY Church preaching the TRUE GOSPEL today. God raised up His Only True Church through his end-time Apostle (and Elijah), Herbert W. Armstrong. To be a member of this Church, you must believe that the Trinity is satanic, that the Holy Spirit is only the mind of God (not a person), and that HWA was given the commission to preach the TRUE GOSPEL, which was completely lost to the world until HWA restored it in 1934. You must believe every publication put out by His True Church as God's true instructions to mankind. You must believe that the United States and Great Britain are the descendants of Ephraim and Manasseh and are present day remnant of Israel. You must keep the seventh-day Sabbath strictly according to O.T. law, even if it means losing your job. You must stop celebrating Christmas and other satanic holidays and replace them with God's Holy Days (annual Sabbaths). You must take off of work to keep these days. You must pay three tithes (the 3rd tithe every 3rd year), along with generous offerings, including to the building fund. You must send the money to Headquarters in Pasadena2 (et. al) and NEVER question how it is used. You must not celebrate birthdays.  You must not eat unclean foods. You must not seek medical care or go to doctors--to do so shows your lack of faith in God as Healer. You must believe in God's Government and its top down structure (God the Father, Jesus Christ the Son, HWA, Ministers, Elders, Deacons) and obey all they command. To disobey the Government is to disobey God. You must never leave the Church or you will be cast into the Lake of Fire. You will also be left behind when its time to go to the Place of Safety.  You may ask "safe questions." But if we detect that you "know too much," we will separate you from the group and mark you from the pulpit so others will stay away from you. You are to give up all individuality and conform to our standards of dress, hair length, dating, etc. (For more, read: Without My Informed Consent!) If you are still interested in membership, please feel free to speak to one of our representatives.

If you were told all these things up front, would you have become a member? Because you weren't told these things, doesn't that fall under the category of "deception"?  If a group has practiced, or is continuing to practice, deception and cover-up, why do you want to be a part of it?  You may feel you joined "God's Church" because God called you and you "proved all things." Was that really true? When you were believing that this organization was the "one and only true Church of God," there were, at the same time, thousands of other groups in society which were deceiving their recruits by using very similar words and methods. These methods have been described as thought reform or mind control. Most people who come into these groups are excited because they think they have found the "true Gospel" and "the purpose of life." They find loyalty, sacrifice, dedication, instant friendships and "black and white answers" to problems. But the belief system goes far beyond that and instills fear into you (fear of being disfellowshipped, fear of leaving the group, fear of asking too many questions, fear of displeasing God, fear of losing the Holy Spirit and fear of not receiving eternal life. You end up being psychologically abused, manipulated and exploited.  

If you are presently in the Worldwide Church of God, I hope you have the courage and conviction to question and evaluate whether you really want to be a part of any religious organization that deceived people into believing that it was the "only true Church where salvation could be attained" and then changed their doctrines by using confusion, deceit, blame, contradictions, and propaganda, whitewashed their founder, revised their history, and sold the copyrights to HWA's literature to Philadelphia Church of God for $3 million dollars.

You also should ask yourself why the WCG is now endorsing false and new age teachers such as Richard J. Foster, Rick Warren and Brian McLaren, along with contemplative spirituality?

Much more about the history, changes and direction of the "new" WCG today can be found in the articles listed under: Research Info on Worldwide Church of God.

For more info about reasons behind WCG's "transformation" and how doctrine was used as a massive propaganda tool, read: Outsider's Inside Update Newsletters (especially this part in OIU Newsletter #3 pt 1: "Was There a Choice?), and links at the end of this article.

Read: Was God Behind the Worldwide Church of God Changes?

Also see: Why are you so critical of the new WCG? (Q&A)

If you are in any of the splinter groups that still believes God used Herbert Armstrong, please take time to read some of our articles under Questioning Herbert W. Armstrong.

Lastly, challenge yourself by studying how mind-manipulating, exploitive groups in our society function. We have a number of books listed on our Booklist and articles which will help you to understand mind control and propaganda. You owe it to yourself to investigate these things.

May God give you true discernment.

By Kelly Marshall and D. Williams
Exit & Support Network™
January 6, 2001
Last updated February 3, 2008

"What luck for rulers that people do not think." ~ Adolf Hitler

 

Footnote:

1 The word "cult" is used in the context of a deceitful, abusive, mind-manipulating organization. (See: Identifying Marks of an Exploitive, Abusive Group.) While Worldwide Church of God may not be labeled a "religious cult" today, we have given reasons in the OIU newsletters and shown in other articles why we do not endorse them, but rather expose them. For thoughts on why WCG would find it advantageous to mainstream, see this part in OIU Newsletter #2. 

2 In November 2004 the Worldwide Church of God moved its headquarters from Pasadena to Glendora, California. (Pasadena Star-News, October 25, 2004) By May 2006 all their offices were moved to Glendora. (Together May-June 2006). They are now considering a name change. Read: Worldwide Church of God is Changing Their Name


An Open Letter to Our Acquaintances in The Church of God (Very important letter which enabled many to question deception and to exit WCG and its authoritarian offshoots.)

Research Information on Worldwide Church of God  

Questioning Herbert W. Armstrong (was he who he said he was?)

Where Do I Find the "One True Church?"

Understanding Mind Control & Exploitive Groups

Back to Articles on Exposing/Judging  


 

 

Home  About Us   Contents  Q&A   What's New  
    Search  Stories  OIU Newsletters  WCG Info  Email Us  Letters
Child Survivors  Articles for Survivors  Mike's Enlightenment Page (PCG)  
  Booklist  Tapes  Links & Resources  Referrals