Gerald Flurry claims that faith to be healed and
faith to be resurrected is the same faith. Is this true? This article
(based on the sermon given on October 6, 2004, San Diego, CA, "The Faith
of Christ" Pt. 3) will help you to stop and compare GF's teachings with
the Word of God and to see what true faith really is. Only certain parts
of the sermon are quoted. Green type is ESN's words. GF=Gerald Flurry.
GF: I wanted to speak and give another sermon on the book of John,
and I knew that there was something about John 11...
"I am crucified with Christ: nevertheless I live; yet not I, but Christ
liveth in me: and the life which I now live in the flesh I live by the
faith of the Son of God..." (Galatians 2:20)
The faith of the Son of God
"...who loved me, and gave himself for me."
The very same faith, Paul said, the very same faith of Christ; that
faith that He had on this earth, and that He has. Paul said, "I live by
that. I have the very same faith, the faith of Christ."
ESN: Is this
what Paul is saying here? Does "the faith of Christ" really mean we must
have Christ's faith? Or is Flurry attempting to rewrite Scripture?
According to the best Greek scholarship, Flurry is wrong. W. E. Vine, in
dealing with the preposition "of," explains:
"In the Authorized Version 'the faith of' is sometimes ambiguous;
with reference to Christ it is objective; i. e., faith in Him, not
His own faith, in the following passages in which the R. V., 'in'
gives the correct meaning, Rom. 3:22; Gal. 2:16 (twice), 20, R. V., 'I
live in faith, the faith which is in the Son of God;' 3:22; Eph. 3:12;
Phil. 3:9, (cp. Col. 2:12, 'faith in the working of God')."1
[emp. mine]
The Greek word for "faith" in Galatians 2:20 is pistis and in
this verse means "reliance upon Christ for salvation."
"I heard of your faith in the Lord Jesus," (Ephesians 1:15).
[emp. mine]
GF: (Quotes John 11:8): "His disciples say unto him, Master, the
Jews of late sought to stone thee; and goest thou thither again?"
And the way Christ conducted the Work was not how dangerous it
was; if Word had to be done there, He just said, "Look, we have to go back
and do it.
And we face problems and trials like that, ourselves. Sometimes we
just simply have to walk into harm's way because, well, something has
to be done. [emp. mine]
(Talks about the Scriptures where Jesus raised Lazarus from the grave.)
So Christ is correcting them, and He wants to correct all of us from
time-to-time, because, brethren, this is the kind of faith that
gets us healed. I mean healed in this life, healed or
resurrected from the dead. It's the same faith. And Christ was trying to
get them to see, look, remember it talks about in James, raising him up?
When you anoint a person you raise him up, a type of the resurrection and
Christ is trying to get them to see, look, it's really the same faith
that causes you to be healed, that it does in the resurrection,
because in fact, many people are healed in the resurrection. We know that.
[emp. mine]
ESN: The words
in James (5:15) about "the prayer of faith shall save the sick, and the
Lord shall raise him up" does not say that it is God's will for Christians
to always be healed. If that were true, none of them would ever die. Some
commentators say the word "sick" is literally "weary one" and this verse
refers to spiritual restoration, not physical, since the verse goes on to
say, "and if he have committed sins, they shall be forgiven him." Many who
have taken this verse to refer solely to physical healing have remained
ill, or have ended up dying.
GF: Mr. Armstrong—do you remember years ago when he said, "I
stopped breathing. I stopped breathing."
And through the nurse resuscitating him, he came back to life. He said,
"I actually stopped breathing."
Now he was healed and he was resurrected in that sense. Wasn't he?
Healed and resurrected.
ESN: Many people have stopped breathing and
have been resuscitated through modern medical technology; i. e., CPR or
heart massage. Does this mean that they were "healed" and "resurrected"?
Was HWA healed of his heart condition? If this was true, he wouldn't have
continued to have heart problems and doctors the rest of his life.2
GF: Now, again, you see, James says if you anoint a person, the
prayer of faith shall raise him up. A type of that resurrection. It's the
same faith required for both, for both the healing and the resurrection.
ESN: Where does it say in Scripture that it
takes the same kind of faith to be healed, as it takes to be
resurrected? We are told to pray "according to the will of God." (I John
5:14) Whether we are healed, or not healed, depends on His will for our
lives. Moreover, Christians will be resurrected when Christ returns
because of placing their faith and trust in Jesus Christ as the Son of
God, not by working up their own faith to be resurrected..
"I am the resurrection, and the life: he that believeth in me,
though he were dead, yet shall he live:" (John 11:25). [emp.
mine]
"And this is the will of him that sent me, that every one which
seeth the Son, and believeth on him, may have everlasting life:
and I will raise him up at the last day." (John 6:40). [emp.
mine]
Nothing is said in the above verses about having "the prayer of faith"
in order to be resurrected to eternal life. Flurry somehow believes that
being resuscitated is the same as being "resurrected."
GF: Now, Mr. Armstrong didn't want to come back to life. He asked
God right after that, "Well, God, if you don't have anything more for me
to do, please let me die."
ESN: Is this what HWA said? Or is GF
embellishing Armstrong's words? Here are quotes from HWA's exact words to
the brethren in 1978 concerning this incident:
"First, I want to say a few words about my illness. Last August I
was scripturally dead. The doctor called it heart failure. ... The
nurse's estimate from the time she had noticed this until I began
taking the first breath was at least thirty seconds. She said
it was a minute and a half, though, that it was touch and go, because
I'd lapse back and quit breathing. And after about a minute and a half
I was breathing enough on my own, and I've continued all right since,
and I hope the rest of the life that God wants for me on earth.
...
Shortly after they'd told me what had happened, I felt that if my
work in God's hands were finished and God didn't have any further use
for me in His Work, that I would rather have remained dead.
Because if they hadn't intervened I would have been buried in two or
three days. (Excerpts from Address to the 1978 Ministerial Conference.
March 1978) [emp. mine]
HWA said he would rather have remained dead, not "please let me die."
Then he went on to say that God had shown him something by "two miracles."
One was supposed to be because he was restored when he was "past
eighty-five years of age," and the other was because neither he nor his
nurses had "ever heard of anyone his age being restored by that process
after almost complete loss of mind, my brain virtually a vegetable. And I
was restored with my mind just as intact as it ever was." (Excerpts from
Address to the 1978 Ministerial Conference. March 1978)
HWA took a 30 second lack of breathing incident and turned into
a "miracle" because (according to him) he was God's instrument to "get the
Work done." This places HWA in a special category in members' eyes. If HWA
had been dead four days like Lazarus was and then came back to life, it
would have been much more of a "miracle" than it was made out to be. (HWA
was known to have added to this story later, saying that "God raised him
from the dead."3)
GF: He was tired; he was worn out. And you know something brethren?
He came back, and said he did more in that next seven years than he did in
all the rest of his life, combined.
ESN: HWA and his WCG were exposed for
corruption and scandals, starting in the late 1960's.4
Is this doing more than he did in all the rest of his life? The work of
HWA wasn't the work of God.
GF: I can remember his son coming to one area that I was in, and
when he was speaking, he said, "My father says he stopped
breathing."
Now, that's the way he put it. "My father says he stopped breathing."
I think he implied, well, he didn't believe that. Isn't that amazing?
Isn't that amazing, that his own son didn't even believe what his father
said? And somehow didn't think that God—God, brethren, could
just let a man stop breathing, and then start him up again? [bolding
mine]
Is it a small issue if you can't believe God can start a man breathing
again?
ESN: Flurry says that it was "God" that let
him stop breathing, and "God" that "started him up again."
HWA says:
"Had not skilled nurses been present to administer instant
mouth-to-mouth resuscitation and heart massage, I tell you that as far
as I was personally concerned I wouldn't be here today.
HWA had heart failure (for 30 seconds) in the hospital and his resuming
breathing was due to the intervention of the nurses and staff.
GF: Or bring him up out of the grave like He did with Lazarus? You
can imagine what that would do in this world today. They'd never let
you get away with that, raising somebody from the dead. [emp.
mine]
ESN: First, GF talks about God raising
Lazarus and then he transfers raising people from the dead to an act that
the members might do. The miracles of Jesus in the gospels were a
testimony to the Jews that He was who He said He was—the Messiah, the Son
of God.
GF: But I'll tell you, I believe there's a big chasm between where
Mr. Herbert Armstrong is and where his son is, Garner Ted Armstrong.
That's just what I believe.
ESN: Since GF believes all go to the same
place (the grave), what does he mean that there's "a big chasm" between
where HWA and GTA are? Where is HWA supposed to be? In heaven? And GTA is
in hell?
GF: We've seen a lot of people do some strange things, that
are inside God's Church today, and you and I are going to have to be
awfully serious about building our faith, and I'm talking about faith that
will get us healed and get us resurrected, that will raise us up.
Whether it's now or in the future, what difference does it make, if it's
God will?
ESN: GF again bases being healing and being
resurrected on having a certain kind of faith, which is not Scriptural.
Our resurrection will be because of Christ's all atoning sacrifice on the
cross and our faith and trust in Him.
GF: Now, Mr. Armstrong said, near the end of his life, that he
didn't think his son was ever converted...
ESN: Did HWA say this because of the
known immorality of his son? Then
where does that leave HWA? Was he not an habitual liar and a hypocrite? (as shown in
many places on this site) Read:
Mystery of the Ages (a critical review) and accompanying research articles)
GF: ...but even if he wasn't, brethren, that doesn't absolutely
mean he's going to be resurrected in that
resurrection pictured tomorrow.
ESN: Now here is some strange double-talk. GF
is saying that even if someone isn't converted, it doesn't mean they will
come up in what HWA called "the second resurrection," or "Great White
Throne Judgment." Yet GF has taught that one "must" remain converted in
order to come up in the first resurrection to life eternal. So what
resurrection is left for GTA? The "third resurrection" (that GF teaches),
which is supposed to be the resurrection to the lake of fire?
GF: [Jews in Sodom and Gomorrah] knew who this Man was; they
knew He was from God. They knew He came from another world. They
just couldn't bring themselves to trust Him, and to believe in
somebody that came from another world... [emp. mine]
ESN: What other "world" is GF referring to
that he says the pre-incarnate Christ came from? Doesn't the Bible say He
came from heaven?
GF: Now, the way I look on that is, that when Mr. Armstrong died, I
think God did that—we could say that's a Lazarus on a small scale...
ESN: HWA being
resuscitated after not breathing for 30 seconds is a "Lazarus on a small
scale"?? That's a mighty small scale.
GF: God wouldn't want to do something like that today because,
well, they'd probably never forget it, and maybe it might cause us more
problems than it's worth today. ...
ESN: What is GF saying here? Is he trying to
give the members a reason for why his wife wasn't "resurrected from the
dead"? If God "raised HWA from the dead" (i. e., "brought him back"), then
why couldn't He do the same thing today as he did in 1978? While God
could perform any miracle He wants, how much is this occurring in the
world today in a genuine manner? The disciples not only raised the dead in
the first century, but they also had the ability to take up deadly snakes
and drink poison! (Matthew 10:8) No mention of that here.
GF: Doesn't that help your faith to grow? I mean, we're talking
about faith in being able to be healed, faith in being able to be
resurrected; it's the same faith. But if you don't have the faith to be
healed, how can you be resurrected?
ESN: Instead of helping the brethren's faith
"to grow," this seems like a fear tactic. What GF is saying is that if
members don't have enough faith, not only will they not be healed; they
just might not get resurrected! What a fearful thought to think your
own resurrection depends on having a certain kind of faith instead of
resting on the Words of Scripture.
"And this is the will of him that sent me, that every one which
seeth the Son, and believeth on him, may have everlasting life: and
I will raise him up at the last day" (John 6:40). [emp. mine]
GF: (Quotes John 11:21) "Then said Martha unto Jesus, Lord, if thou
hadst been here, my brother had not died."
So she's making that ridiculous statement. [emp. mine]
ESN: What is "ridiculous" about wanting your
own brother not to die?
GF: (quotes John 11:24) "Martha saith unto him, I know that he
shall rise again in the resurrection at the last day."
Now, brethren, tomorrow pictures the resurrection of the Last Day, and
here's a lady that KNEW that he was going to be resurrected then and he
would be in that resurrection and that God would take care of him, and her
faith was deplorable! And she KNEW about and BELIEVED in the
resurrection that is pictured tomorrow. She BELIEVED it. But then, Satan
does, too. He believes in that day. He believes in God's Plan.
ESN: GF shows an incredible lack of
mercy and compassion toward Martha. Of this passage,
J. Vernon McGee says,
"Martha believed in a resurrection. But listen, it makes less
demand upon faith to believe that in a future day we shall receive
glorified bodies than it does to rest now on the assurance that they
that wait upon the Lord shall renew their strength. ...although Martha
knew from the Old Testament that there would be a resurrection from
the dead, she didn't believe that Jesus could help her now." (Thru
the Bible With J. Vernon McGee, Vol. 3, p. 439)
This passage of Scripture is saying just the opposite of what GF
is trying to make it say! Martha wanted her brother to be delivered
from death; Jesus wanted him to be triumphant over death.5
Martha needed instruction, which Jesus gave. He never told her that her
faith was "deplorable."
GF: There's no difference, really, in the faith to resurrect
somebody from the dead, or to believe in the Great White Throne Judgment,
or some resurrection. We're going to have to have FAITH to come up out of
the grave, or to come alive when Jesus Christ gets here.
ESN: Christ is the one who saves us and
Christ is the One who resurrects us. Our hope in the resurrection
is based upon Christ's resurrection from the dead.
"For as in Adam all die, even so in Christ shall all be made
alive" (I Corinthians 15:22). [emp. mine]
"Blessed be the God and Father of our Lord Jesus Christ, which
according to his abundant mercy hath begotten us again unto a
lively [living] hope by the resurrection of Jesus Christ
from the dead," (I Peter 1:3) [emp. mine]
GF: Now, Jesus Christ was upset with these people, and I'm sure
at times He's upset with us. You know He is, considering what we do.
[emp. mine]
ESN: Does the Bible say Christ is upset with
us? This goes completely contrary to His love for His children.
"Who shall separate us from the love of Christ?" (Romans 8:35).
[The answer as you read on is "nothing."]
"Wherefore in all things it behoved him to be made like unto his
brethren, that he might be a merciful and faithful high
priest" (Hebrews 2:17). [emp. mine]
"For I will be merciful to their unrighteousness, and their
sins and their iniquities will I remember no more" (Hebrews 8:12).
[emp. mine]
"To the praise of the glory of his grace, wherein he hath made us
accepted in the beloved" (Ephesians 1:6). [emp. mine]
GF: Now look, He does resurrect people from the dead, and I have
ABSOLUTELY NO DOUBT IN MY MIND that he resurrected Mr. Armstrong, just
brought him back to life. Brought him back to life, and he didn't even
want to go on living. He knew how helpless he was, and how
hard it was, how difficult it was to go on doing the work at
the age he had to do it, and he didn't want to do it. But God figured,
"Well, that's no good. That's good that you're that age. Then you'll rely
upon Me more! And not yourself."
ESN: What is GF saying here? No matter how
tired and burdened you are, no matter how hard it is, you will want to
keep going—just like HWA did. Don't think about how God promises to give
us comfort and encouragement, just think about how HWA did it, and so can
you.
GF: If Mr. Armstrong did more in those last seven years than he did
ALL the rest of his life, and he wanted to die because he was so old and
weak, well, then there must be a great value in those trials we're going
through, wouldn't you think, sometimes when we're awfully weak, sometimes
when we'd rather, maybe, have somebody else do the job instead of us doing
it?
ESN: Do you feel the pressure, guilt and
heavy burdens that GF has just placed on the members? No matter how tired,
no matter how old, no matter how weak—they better keep pushing on; they
better keep praying, striving, sending in their tithes and offerings,
having faith, or they won't make it. No rest. But what did Christ say?
"Come unto me, all ye that labour and are heavy laden, and I
will give you rest. Take my yoke upon you, and learn of me; for I
am meek and lowly in heart: and ye shall find rest unto your souls.
For my yoke is easy, and my burden is light." (Matthew 11:28-30).
[emp. mine]
This is the rest of salvation. And it is available by
coming to Him and placing your faith and trust in
Him as your personal Savior. If we think there is something else we
have to do, then we have failed to understand Christ's finished work for
us on the cross. The work has already been completed.
GF: Now, brethren I'm saying this in love. I love all of you very
much and I know you're God's people.
ESN: Does he love them? If so, why no mention
of the Savior's love for them?
GF: But I do want you to consider seriously the truth that
God is giving you at this Feast, and I think that's why God wanted me to
get more into this. He's concerned about YOU, and He wants to know that
you go away from here and you really use what you're learning to
TRUST Him, whether it be to heal or face any problem that's out there.
ESN: GF is giving the same message HWA
thundered out: "Now that you've received the truth, you are responsible
for it!" What truth?? The truth is in Christ Jesus. The truth is knowing
Him and receiving His salvation. He said, "I am the way, the truth
and the life." (John 14:6) [emp. mine]
"And the Word was made flesh, and dwelt among us, (and we beheld
his glory, the glory as of the only begotten of the Father,) full of
grace and truth." (John 1:14). [emp. mine]
"For the law was given by Moses, but grace and truth came by
Jesus Christ." (John 1:17). [emp. mine]
GF: There isn't ANYTHING we can't do, and the biggest flaw we could
have is looking and trusting ourselves. That's the biggest flaw of all.
ESN: In other words he is saying that they
can be healed, they can rise from the dead, they can keep going ...
anything, they can do it, and if they don't, they have looked to
themselves and they are flawed.
GF: If we really and truly, deep down, believe—here's the
point—really deep down, believe in that resurrection that's pictured
tomorrow and the first resurrection, we also believe that God will heal us
right now. Now, of course, there's always the possibility He won't. He
might let us die, but we're still going to be healed. It really doesn't
make that much difference, as long as we're doing God's will. It doesn't
really matter.
ESN: Believing we can be healed is connected
with believing in the resurrection. However, GF says God "might" let them
die (as we assume happened with his wife), but it "really doesn't make
that much difference" and "it really doesn't matter." What a statement!
Grieving for loved ones who have died evidently doesn't mean very much as
far as GF is concerned. What does the Word of God say?
"Precious in the sight of the LORD is the death of his saints."
(Psalm 116:15)
"Blessed are they that mourn: for they shall be comforted" (Matthew
5:4).
GF: The problem is—if we don't get these words in our mind and
begin to apply them .... when Mr. Armstrong died and had to be brought
back to life, and if He can't reach us in teaching through examples like
that, HOW is He going to reach us? Well, it's only gong to be through
suffering, isn't it?
ESN: GF is telling them that if they
don't do what he has told them, they are going to suffer (yet many
of them are already suffering).
GF: Do you know about the Laodiceans? Do you know why they're going
to suffer, and suffer, and suffer, as perhaps nobody in the Great
Tribulation? because they know they could have avoid it.
ESN: The "Laodiceans" to PCG are not only
those in the
Worldwide Church of God, but all those who aren't in the PCG and don't
trust what GF is saying. GF has put himself up in the place of God in the
minds of the members. Fear of suffering in the Great Tribulation
keeps them from leaving.
GF: They won't BELIEVE! And there's no excuse for their unbelief!
There's no excuse for their lack of faith!
ESN: There is nothing in Revelation that says
the church of the Laodiceans won't believe. It says they are lukewarm. The
Laodiceans made their boast in material possessions. It had to do with
worldly wealth. Does this describe the members in PCG, or does it sound
more like Gerald Flurry? The Laodiceans had no
love of Christ, no preaching of grace.
GF: And so I'm really telling you how to avoid some suffering.
Mr. Armstrong had some wonderful books on healing, a booklet on healing,
and one on faith. ...we need to read them from time-to-time and keep
working on building our faith, and accept the tests that God gives us,
because it really is good for you. [emp. mine]
ESN: What GF is
telling them will almost guarantee suffering. HWA's healing booklet
has caused countless people to die because they didn't go to the medical
establishment when they needed to. There is nothing "good" in placing our
trust in a man and failing to exercise wisdom and good judgment.
Faith in the Bible relates to our faith in Christ as the Son of
God. This faith has to do with salvation. But to have "faith" that you
are going be healed and don't need a doctor could have dire
consequences.
GF: (Quotes John 11:25) "Jesus said unto her, I am the
resurrection, and the life: he that believeth in me, though he were dead,
yet shall he live:"
I mean, here's a bold statement. This man standing right there before
her said, "Look, I AM the resurrection. I'm the one that's going to
resurrect all those people on the Last Great Day."
ESN: GF is adding words. Jesus does not
say in this passage of Scripture that He is going to resurrect people on
the "Last Great Day." There is no Jewish feast day called the "Last Great
Day." Furthermore, you won't find it anywhere in the Bible. This idea is
what HWA concocted by putting together the words "...on the eighth day"
from Leviticus 23:36,39 and "the last day" plus "great day of the feast"
from John 7:37.
When Jesus says, "...he that believeth in me, though he were dead..."
this refers to spiritual death. But to have Jesus is to have life.
"He that heareth my word, and believeth on him that sent me, hath
everlasting life, and shall not come into condemnation; but is
passed from death unto life" (John 5:24) [emp. mine]
GF: "I'M the one that's going to be used to resurrect those people
in the first resurrection. Are you telling Me I can't bring somebody up
out of the grave NOW?"
I mean, He was incredulous!
ESN: GF is portraying a false Jesus here; a
Jesus without humility, love, mercy and compassion. Jesus was not
incredulous. He was instructing Martha.
GF: (Quotes John 11:26) "And whosoever liveth and believeth in me
shall never die. Believest thou this?"
He's asking them. Do you believe that someone—I mean, really, brethren,
this is heavy, heavy, heavy and wonderful truth. But he says, "Whosoever
lives and believes in Me shall never die. Do you believe that?"
ESN: Those who have trusted Jesus have
eternal life at that very moment and shall never die spiritually for their
sins, because Jesus has died in their place. How much does GF really
understand what Jesus is saying in this verse?
GF: Well, I certainly think you do, but we need to work on building
our faith; we need more of that.
ESN: Faith works by love and it's acting on
what God has said. While there are graces we add to our faith (2 Peter
1:5-7), there is nothing mentioned in the Bible about "working on building
our faith." Instead we are to "grow in grace and in the knowledge of our Lord
and Savior Jesus Christ." (II Peter 3:18)
"...faith which worketh by love" (Galatians 5:6).
"So then faith cometh by hearing, and hearing by the word of God"
(Romans 10:17).
GF: I mean, you're going to be the Bride of Jesus Christ! You have
noticed how He looks, right? I know you have, because we keep pounding
away at it and pounding away at it at the Feast of Tabernacles.
[emp. GF's]
ESN: Do true
ministers of God need to "keep pounding away" at their members?
"But we were gentle among you, even as a nurse cherisheth
her children:" (I Thessalonians 2:7). [emp. mine]
"Now I Paul myself beseech you by the meekness and gentleness of
Christ," II Corinthians 10:1).
GF: He's asking us, "Do you believe? Do you really believe this?"
Because 95% of God's people don't. Let's be honest; let's not sugarcoat
this. Let's look at it the way it really is. Do you believe this? The
Laodiceans don't.
ESN: Where does GF get the figure that 95% of
God's people don't believe they were called to be the Bride of Christ?
This would leave only 5% as believing. That is absolutely absurd and has
no biblical basis whatsoever.
GF: The healing promise includes the resurrection. But you
can't just say, well, just because you believe in the last Great Day or
the first resurrection, that you have the faith to get you there.
... Why should it seem strange that the Head of this Church, who IS the
resurrection, would maybe cause Mr. Armstrong's heart to start beating
again? I mean, come! Where's the logic in that? Is Jesus Christ REALLY the
Head of this Church, or isn't He? If He IS, that's NOTHING!
But that's what Christ was dealing with here. It doesn't make any
difference which resurrection it is, or if it's a resurrection today. It's
still the same.
ESN: What is GF trying to get across here? Is
he saying that all who died with a disease (including his wife) will be
"healed" in the resurrection? The Bible shows us that in the first
resurrection we will have a body like unto Christ's glorious body. Nothing
is said about being "healed in the resurrection."
"..but we know that, when he shall appear, we shall be like him";
(I John 3:2)
"Who shall change our vile body, that it may be fashioned like unto
his glorious body," (Philippians 3:21)
According to GF, unless the remaining 5% of them "believe" they can't
be healed, but whether they get healed now or in one of the resurrections
"doesn't make any difference." Does this make sense?
GF: But I want you to see, brethren of God, how the Head of our
Church felt about that. Please notice this. (Quotes John 11:32) "Then when
Mary was come where Jesus was, and saw him, she fell down at his feet,
saying unto him, Lord, if thou hadst been here, my brother had not died."
Well, here we go again. That's the sister. You know how it is in
families, they tend to think alike. So here she comes along and she thinks
the same way.
ESN: GF's judgmental and insensitive attitude
toward women is shown by his words. The way Jesus treated women is
revealed in the Scriptures. Jesus was always merciful and compassionate.
Martha doubted and needed instruction; Mary wept and needed comfort. Jesus
met both of them in their need.
GF: (Quotes John 11:33) "When Jesus therefore saw her weeping, and
the Jews also weeping which came with her..."
I mean they were really, really crying and mourning the death of
Lazarus. They were all weeping.
"...weeping which came with her, he groaned in the spirit, and was
troubled,"
Because they were just out of control in their weeping, as it
were, compared to what Jesus Christ said it should have been..
[emp. mine]
ESN: Since when is weeping for a loved one
that has died considered being "out of control"? But those who are
unfeeling and callous, it would be.
GF: And then he groaned in His Spirit and was troubled. Do you
think sometimes we trouble Jesus Christ, brethren? Do you think sometimes
He groans about what we do and how we conduct ourselves? I think so. I
mean, I'm just being honest with you in love for you; I'm not trying to
beat you down AT ALL, but we must face reality. And God is not going to
give us all this wonderful future here unless we really believe,
and have His faith in us, the very same faith He has.
ESN: What cruel, uncaring, lying words! GF
says he is not trying to beat them down, but what else could this be
called?! He has given a totally false picture of the Lord Jesus and
has left the members feeling guilty, unloved by Christ, unable to measure
up, and afraid that they won't inherit eternal life unless they
"really believe" and have the "same faith" Christ had. As shown at the
beginning of this article, it is faith in Christ that saves.
Eternal life is a free gift and we can know that we have it:
"For God so loved the world, that he gave his only begotten Son,
that whosoever believeth in him should not perish, but have
everlasting life" (John 3:16 [emp. mine]
"And I give unto them eternal life; and they shall never perish,
neither shall any man pluck them out of my hand" (John 10:28). [emp.
mine]
"These things have I written unto you that believe on the name of
the Son of God; that ye may know that ye have eternal life, and
that ye may believe on the name of the Son of God" (I John 5:13).
[emp. mine]
GF: (Quotes John 11:36) "Jesus wept." And how many of us have
memorized that as a child. Jesus wept. All these people were crying around
there, and you know what it did? It made Jesus Christ weep, only He was
weeping for something far different than what they were.
You see, we can get too carried away with death. Well, it's such a
terrible thing, he's dead. It really is not a huge factor in the
overall plan of God. [emp. mine]
Jesus Christ cried! Because they didn't believe! And they should have!
ESN: GF again shows his incredible lack of
compassion for those who have lost a loved one. Contrary to what GF
thinks, this verse shows the heart of God. When we go through times of
sorrow and affliction He is there, He cares, He weeps with us.
John G. Mitchell wrote,
"Three times our Lord is said to have wept. He wept over Jerusalem
(Luke 19:41). He wept in the garden (Hebrews 5:7). And here in John
11, He wept at the tomb of Lazarus. And all three passages use a
different word. Here is the infinite God entering into the sorrows,
the afflictions, the wounded hearts of others. He was one with them."6
[emp. mine]
GF: (Quotes: John 11:42) "And I knew that thou hearest me always:"
Now, brethren, our faith is not perfect, but we need to know that God
always hears us if we're praying in faith. ... That's what this
chapter is all about. He's saying, "Look, you people cannot make it if you
don't just get away from that human faith, and begin to have the faith
that I have! And I KNOW that My Father always hears Me." [emp. mine]
And He thanked Him before He even resurrects Lazarus. How about that
for faith?
ESN: Jesus said what He did so that the
people would believe on Him. The rest of the verse (which GF didn't quote)
reads:
"but because of the people which stand by I said it, that they
may believe that thou hast sent me."
It was all for the glory of God. This verse has nothing to do with our
having enough faith, or the right kind of faith, to get our prayers
answered.
GF: I'm telling you, the stakes are awfully high, and most of God's
people have not passed the test...
ESN: Healing and being in the resurrection is
not a matter of "passing the test." Whether we are healed, or not, depends
on the will of God. Being in the first resurrection is a result of
placing our faith in Jesus as the Son of
God.
GF: ...if we don't really search for all the fragments, as I
was saying before, and really learn everything we can at the Feast, we
won't build that kind of faith. But if we do that, we will. We will.
That's a promise from God. This is a relationship.
ESN: This is not a relationship that GF is
describing. This is bondage.
"For ye have not received the spirit of bondage again to fear; but
ye have received the Spirit of adoption, whereby we cry, Abba, Father"
(Romans 8:15).
GF: See, if you had real faith you'd stand there and you'd talk to
your Father the way Jesus Christ did, and you'd bring the Father into the
picture. ... If you have the Father in the picture, you know you're
a son and you know that you're going to enter into His family, the
Father's always foremost in your mind because He's building His family,
and He always hears you, unless you're sinning.
ESN: GF berates the members for not having
"real faith" while the Word of God instructs us to place our faith in
Christ, to believe in Him, and that He becomes the Mediator between us and
the Father. (I Timothy 2:5) To know Him is to know the Father, who already
is in the picture.
...he that hath seen me hath seen the Father; and how sayest thou
then, Show us the Father? (John 14:9)
The Spirit itself beareth witness with our spirit, that we are the
children of God: (Romans 8:16)
GF: (Quotes John 11:43-45 about Jesus raising Lazarus). ...maybe
the more John thought about it and thought about it and Christ worked on
his mind, because he lived to be this old man, then he began to say,
"Whoa! We didn't even get that example! We didn't even understand what
Christ was talking about! We didn't even know that He was trying to
show us the kind of faith that we have to have if we're going to be
martyrs, if we're going to have to die.
ESN: Who is the "we" that John is supposed to
have said didn't understand what Christ was talking about? The Scriptures
show that the entire church at this time turned the world upside down
(Acts 17:6), raised the dead (Matthew 10:8; Acts 20:9-12), had great faith
(Romans 1:8) etc. And many Christians down through the century died as
martyrs without renouncing their faith in Christ.
GF: And all of them did, except John, and he went through prison
camp. ... I'm not trying to put him above the others, at all, but I'm just
saying that he had a lot of time to study and think and pray and analyze,
"What did Christ mean by this example?"
ESN: Most scholars affirm that Revelation was
written in A. D. 95 or 96 (when John was on the Island of Patmos) and
after Domitian died in A. D. 96, John was allowed to return to
Ephesus where he wrote his epistles about A. D. 100). Did John set around
studying, thinking, praying, analyzing? Or did he write what Jesus Christ,
through His Holy Spirit, inspired him to write?
GF: And I think yesterday on the plane God just decided to give me
more understanding. Now, I call that revelation!
ESN: Is God giving "revelations" today? Or
are we to listen to His Son and what He has revealed in the inspired Word
of God?
"God, who at sundry times and in divers manners spake in time past
unto the fathers by the prophets, Hath in these last days
spoken unto us by his Son, ..." (Hebrews 1:1-2) [emp. mine]
GF: I'm nobody, I'm a sinner. I'm not fit to be here, and
I'm not here exalting myself. I hope and pray to God that I'm not.
ESN: Then why does GF want to make the
members think that he has certain "revelations" that God again revealed to
Him? Isn't this putting himself up?
GF: "...it's not going to be long.
We'd better get used to this; it's not going to be long till we're going
to meet David, and Abraham, and Isaac, and Jacob, and all these great men
of the Bible. It isn't going to be long.
ESN: Didn't HWA, for decades, say that it
"isn't going to be long"?
GF: ...God was just pouring thoughts into my mind ... I was just
told, and I don't know how many people this involved, maybe it's just a
few, maybe it's more than a few, I'm not sure, but some people, anyhow,
that registered to come to the Feast just didn't come. ... Now, I know
there are some legitimate reasons, and please understand I'm not talking
about that, but I'm talking about people that just do that and then they
don't show up, and I'm telling you, brethren, they THINK they have eternal
life. I don't believe they do!
ESN: Anyone that has trusted Christ as their
personal Savior can know (not "think") that they have eternal life:
"He that hath the Son hath life; and he that hath not the Son of
God hath not life. These things have I written unto you that believe
on the name of the Son of God; that ye may know that ye have eternal
life, and that ye may believe on the name of the Son of God" (I John
5:12-13).
GF bases having eternal life with being in Philadelphia Church of God
and attending the Feast. But eternal life is not based on being in a
particular church, or observing certain O.T. feast days. It's based on
being in Christ. It's very helpful to take a Bible concordance and
look up how many times the words "in Christ" appears in the New
Testament.
GF: I think they're dying! Or in some extreme cases, maybe they're
dead spiritually, forever!
ESN: We cannot lose our eternal life.
"And I give unto them eternal life; and they shall never perish,
neither shall any man pluck them out of my hand" (John 10:28). [emp.
mine]
GF: When God gives it to me, I'm afraid not to give it to you. And
I hope that we always have that fear, because that is precisely why we're
here, to learn to fear God. And we'd better fear Him, brethren, and I'm
not taking about the punishment part of it. I'm talking about the reward
that God is going to give you for doing this, for just believing Him.
ESN: GF is greatly concerned about losing
members, which has been happening as more people wake up, realize he is
not speaking for God, and leave. God has not given us a spirit of fear (II
Timothy 1:7). There is no fear in love, because fear has torment. (I John
5:18). Our eternal assurance rests on Christ and what He did for us on the
cross—an all atoning sacrifice—which has enabled us to receive redemption
through His blood; forgiveness of all our sins, past present and future
and our being eternally safe in Him—it does not rest on what we might
think or do.
"Now unto him that is able to do exceeding abundantly above all
that we ask or think, according to the power that worketh in us,"
(Ephesians 3:20). [emp. mine]
GF: We all have too much carnality. Mr. Armstrong said he thought
he was only 51% converted. That probably makes us less than 51%
converted, by a considerable margin, maybe. Well, let's hope not.
ESN: GF tells us that Mr. Armstrong thought
he was "only 51% converted" we must be less than that percentage. Does
this make sense? First of all, becoming converted is not a matter of
degrees, it is a matter of trusting Christ and receiving a new nature.
It's a matter of whosoever will may come. GF emphasizes "carnality." The
Word of God shows that we cannot reform or change the old nature, but we
can walk in the Spirit and have the love of Christ.
GF: So I don't want to have Jesus Christ on my case, for, well, I
mean, really it's pretty dramatic, brethren. Of I had never really
understood John 11 like I do now, it's pretty dramatic that God
sort of crammed it in my head on the way down on Alaska Airlines, of all
places! That's the wonderful God that we serve.
ESN: This doesn't sound like a "wonderful
God." It sounds like a harsh taskmaster that is ready to punish his
subjects for the least infraction.
GF: I mean, the Father wouldn't have sent Jesus Christ down here to
be BUTCHERED and KILLED unless He was serious, would He? If He's that
serious, we must get that serious. ... Why would He come down here and go
through the meat grinder for you? And we need that kind of faith. How did
He get through it? Well, through this faith that I'm talking to you about.
That's how He got through it. That's how He made it through.
ESN: These are coarse and unfeeling words to
describe our Savior's sacrifice! God knew from the foundation of the earth
that His Son would come and willingly die for our sins:
"Who verily was foreordained before the foundation of the world,
but was manifest in these last times for you," (I Peter 1:20).
"...the Lamb slain from the foundation of the world" (Revelation
13:8).
Jesus "made it through" because He was fully God and fully man in His
incarnation.7 He was God in the flesh.
"For in him dwelleth all the fulness of the Godhead bodily"
(Colossians 2:9). [emp. mine]
"And without controversy great is the mystery of godliness: God
was manifest in the flesh..." (I Timothy 3:16)
There was never any question that He might not "get through it."
GF: And I don't care what anybody says, I don't care what those
people that didn't come to this Feast say, I don't care what the
Laodiceans say. at the end of the day, this is going to judge you. The
scriptures can't be broke. It's going to judge all of us.
ESN: As children of God who have trusted Him
as our Savior, we have nothing to fear when Christ returns:
"Verily, verily, I say unto you, He that heareth my word, and
believeth on him that sent me, hath everlasting life, and shall not
come into condemnation; but is passed from death unto life" (John
5:24). [emp. mine]
"And you, that were sometime alienated and enemies in your mind by
wicked works, yet now hath he reconciled In the body of his flesh
through death, to present you holy and unblameable and
unreproveable in his sight:" (Colossians 1:20-22). [emp. mine]
"...he hath made us accepted in the beloved" (Ephesians
1:6).
GF: If Jesus Christ were here today, do you think He would be here?
Do you think He would be here, attending this Feast? Do you think He might
just register and not show up? I mean, this is everything to Him. This is
His life! This is what he died for! And lived for! I think
we all know the answer to that.
ESN: Would Christ be observing days that
pointed to Him and have already been fulfilled through his death and
resurrection? Whether we need to keep the Law for salvation has been
covered elsewhere on this site.8
GF: I mean, God is serious about this because, after all, if the
Father would give His only begotten Son and let God die for our sins, you
know He's serious and He really is putting it all on the line, taking a
chance of losing one of the two gods.
ESN: Where in the Bible does it say that we
will become "gods"? This is an idea that HWA pilfered from the Mormons,9
but it is not scriptural. There are ample verses that show we become
"children of God," "sons of God" and "heirs of God," but never "gods."
GF: Don't you think He's going to require something of us? Well, we
do, and that's why we're here, and I know that, brethren. I know that's
why you're here. But God help us if we let down like that.
ESN: God doesn't "require something of us."
We are saved by His grace and it is His Spirit in us which will produce
works of love.
GF: (Quotes John 20:24-26 about Thomas not believing) "Stick your
fingers into these holes in my hands, and your hand right in my side where
I was SPEARED TO DEATH, and BELIEVE!
ESN: Jesus was not "speared to death." He was
already dead by the time the spear was thrust into Him. The soldier wanted
to make sure He was dead. Jesus willingly gave up His spirit when He died.
This is placed right after they filled a sponge full of vinegar, and put
it on a reed. See the gospel accounts, especially John 19:33-34:
"But when they came to Jesus, and saw that he was dead already,
they brake not his legs: But one of the soldiers with a spear pierced
his side, and forthwith came there out blood and water." [emp. mine]
GF: Well! Now, Thomas ought to have had more faith than that, and
sometimes, brethren, we ought to have more than what we have, and I
include myself. We ought to have more faith. There's some people going to
have to have a gaping hole and Christ standing there to stick their hand
into His side before they can believe? And that kind of faith is going to
get us nowhere.
ESN: The Scripture shows that Thomas loved
Jesus. He had previously said in John 11:16, "...Let us also go, that we
may die with him." Although Thomas missed out on the joy and peace the
other disciples were experiencing after Jesus rose from the dead, Jesus
showed much love and understanding with Thomas. He didn't berate him or
criticize him for his lack of faith, as GF does with the members. Jesus
came especially to see Thomas and to give him proof that He was alive.
J. Vernon McGee says (in referring to these verses) says:
"You will never find a higher testimony to the Lord Jesus than the
one given by Thomas. It is one of the great confessions of Scripture.
For a Jew to say 'My Lord and my God' is the absolute climax."10
How much different this is than GF's rendition.
GF: ...But He wanted Thomas and He wanted all of them to see, "Yes,
that was Me! Yes, that was the Word that became flesh! I was here on this
earth! And they did kill Me because of your sins! I died because of your
sins!
ESN: The Scriptures do not state that Jesus
reprimanded his disciples in this manner whatsoever. He was loving and
kind with them.
GF: And now, brethren, He wants us to believe, and that's the kind
of faith that's going to get us resurrected. ...
ESN: Is that really what is "going to get us
resurrected"? Or is it our faith in Christ?
Has there been any grace (unmerited favor from God) in this sermon? The
grace of God is long-suffering and merciful toward us. This is a
grace that is greater than all our sin.
It is all because of what Jesus has done for us through His death and
resurrection. The depth of this kind of love is hard to fathom.
"In whom we have redemption through his blood, the forgiveness of
sins, according to the riches of his grace"; (Ephesians 1:7).
"But God, who is rich in mercy, for his great love wherewith he
loved us, Even when we were dead in sins, hath quickened us together
with Christ, (by grace ye are saved;)" (Ephesians 2:4-5).
Living the Christian life is not a matter of striving to get through
life, never knowing if we have enough faith, or if we will make it. Faith
is not dependent upon what we see, or how much we try to work it up, it is
based on what the Word of God says. The Lord Jesus has promised He will
sustain us, never forsake us, and will supply our needs day by day, as we
look to Him. To become enmeshed in a system of fear and doubt offers no
assurance of salvation, no peace of mind. In fact, we can have no peace at
all.
Yet Paul tell us:
"Therefore being justified by faith, we have peace with
God through our Lord Jesus Christ: By whom also we have access by
faith into this grace wherein we stand..." (Romans 5:1-2). [emp. mine]
"Through the tender mercy of our God; whereby the dayspring from on
high hath visited us, To give light to them that sit in darkness and
in the shadow of death, to guide our feet into the way of
peace" (Luke 1:78-79) [emp. mine]
This is a God that promises to be there to comfort us in all our
difficulties:
"Blessed be God, even the Father of our Lord Jesus Christ, the
Father of mercies, and the God of all comfort; Who
comforteth us in all our tribulation," (II Corinthians
1:3-4). [emp. mine]
"Now our Lord Jesus Christ himself, and God, even our Father, which
hath loved us, and hath given us everlasting consolation and
good hope through grace, Comfort your hearts, and
stablish you in every good word and work" (II Thessalonians 2:16-17).
[emp. mine]
If we think that we have to do something to please God, or to keep Him
from getting upset with us, we fail to understand these things.
The most important thing any of us can do is to simply take the Word of
God and read it, asking God to make the words real to us. Then we will
find not fear, dread, guilt and shame, but we will find hope, love,
comfort and assurance of eternal salvation.
By
D. W.
Exit & Support Network™
November 19, 2004
Footnotes:
1 Vine's Complete Expository Dictionary of Old
and New Testament Words, W. E. Vine.
2 Charles Hunting on the Clyde Thomas Show, WKIS,
Orlando, FL, 1988. (Tape available.
Email us and mention the Charles Hunting
tape.)
3 March 14, 1980 letter to Roderick C. Meredith
from Herbert W. Armstrong.
4
Letter to
author
Janis Hutchinson from ESN (this part covers HWA's background activities);
Gerringer's 1975 letter to Charles Hunting;
Jack Kessler's 1981 Letter to Worldwide Church of God Board of
Directors;
Richard Place tapes; etc.
5 Excerpted from
An Everlasting Love, by
John G. Mitchell, 1982, p. 212
6 Ibid., p. 216.
7 Read:
Jesus' Two Natures
8 See:
Questions about the Law,
Works or Salvation Ten Commandments,
Works or Salvation
9 See: Chapter Two of ESN critical review of
Mystery of the Ages
10 Thru the Bible with J. Vernon McGee,
Vol. 3, p. 499-500.
Gerald Flurry's Sermon:
Listening to the Dragon (GF
engaged in much shouting and fear tactics during this sermon; partial
transcript; comments by ESN)
Back to Articles on Gerald Flurry
DISCLAIMER:
Posted to facilitate researchers and others with inquiring minds
concerning Gerald Flurry and the Philadelphia Church of God and is for educational and informational purposes only. We encourage our readers to use
discernment and research widely in order to make their own evaluation. All research articles and letters are the
property of Exit & Support Network™. ESN does not endorse all views on outside links.
|
|